Find Your Cruise
Have you tried posting on your roll call over on cruisecritic? May get a better responce.
We have used 'SuperShuttle' (Google it). These are 12 seater minibuses on which you book a shared ride. They drop off other fares in your direction & is a cheap alternative to taxis. If they have got other drop offs along the way, you get a free tour of New York thrown in.